Natural colorants can be processed into polylactic acid (PLA) and polybutylene succinate (PBS) using conventional twin-screw compounding and injection molding, but whether an individual pigment survives depends on how hot the matrix polymer must be run, according to a study of natural pigment-based color masterbatches for biopolymers.
The work, titled "Sustainability in the Development of Natural Pigment-Based Colour Masterbatches and Their Application in Biopolymers", tested four commercial natural pigments: blue spirulina, yellow curcumin, red beetroot and green chlorophyllin. Each was compounded with PLA and PBS into masterbatches on a twin-screw extruder, then let down into the matching polymer at 2, 4 and 6 wt% and injection molded into test specimens. The masterbatch formulation also contained titanium dioxide, calcium carbonate and stearic acid, added to support UV protection, pigment dispersion and processing.
A narrow thermal window
Heat is the central constraint. The organic structures of natural pigments begin to degrade at lower temperatures than the polymers they are meant to color. Thermogravimetric analysis put the degradation onset at roughly 229 °C for spirulina, 244 °C for curcumin, 258 °C for chlorophyllin and 267 °C for beetroot, while PLA and PBS degraded at considerably higher temperatures. The researchers therefore built extrusion profiles that melted each polymer while limiting the pigments' thermal exposure: 145 °C for PBS and 190 °C for PLA, with the twin-screw extruder running at 65 rpm and a feed rate of 2 kg/h.
Spirulina fails in PLA
That window suited most pigment-polymer pairs, with one clear exception. Processed in PLA, spirulina lost its characteristic blue, so no blue PLA masterbatch could be produced. In PBS, whose lower processing temperature is gentler on the pigment, spirulina compounded successfully. The researchers present the result as evidence that pigment compatibility is governed less by the colorant alone than by the thermal processing requirements of the polymer matrix it is paired with.
Flow and mechanical behavior
On the processing side, the pigments caused only limited changes to the matrix. Melt flow rate fell slightly after incorporation, pointing to a modest rise in melt viscosity: neat PLA measured about 50 g/10 min, and the natural-pigment masterbatches stayed close to that figure, with PBS showing a similar, small reduction. The study notes that this matters for compounders, since a natural color system that forced major changes to screw design, pressure settings or molding conditions would have little practical value.
Mechanical properties also held. Across the 2 to 6 wt% addition range, neither polymer showed significant overall losses. PLA started from a Young's modulus of about 1710 MPa and tensile strength of 65.6 MPa, PBS from about 392 MPa and 34.5 MPa, and the colored formulations stayed near those baselines. Impact strength remained in a similar range, though individual pigments produced some variation.
Light stability is the limiting factor
Successful extrusion did not translate into durable color. After 50 hours of xenon-lamp exposure, most formulations showed a color difference above ΔE* = 2, the threshold for a visually perceptible change. The main exception was a PLA formulation containing 2 wt% of the green chlorophyllin masterbatch, which showed the highest photostability. The study identifies UV stability as the largest barrier to wider use, suggesting that packaging, consumer products, agricultural parts and outdoor applications would need additional stabilization, protective coatings or pigment modification before natural colors can match conventional systems over long service periods.
Lower carbon footprint
The environmental comparison favored the natural route under the study's assumptions: one kilogram of curcumin pigment generated about 0.04 kg CO2-eq, against 18.65 kg CO2-eq for the inorganic green reference pigment. The natural-pigment masterbatches also consumed less electricity during extrusion and pelletizing.
The researchers conclude that natural pigment masterbatches still require development, particularly in lightfastness and thermal stability, but that several colorants can be compounded into PLA and PBS on conventional equipment with only limited effects on melt viscosity and mechanical performance. Future work, they suggest, should focus on color stability both during processing and during subsequent service exposure.
